Sunday 10 May 2015

I don't understand why you would want to reduce spending on welfare

The Conservative Manifesto states the party will: "Cap overall welfare spending, lower the amount of benefits that any household can receive to £23,000 and continue to roll out Universal Credit to make work pay."

There are three parts to this statement:
- Lower the amount of benefits that any household can receive
- Roll out Universal Credit
- Make work pay

(See how they lumped the last one together with Universal Credit? Sneaky.)

Ok, here's what I can't understand - how could you vote for any of this?

1. Lower the amount of benefits that any household can receive to £23,000

You might think that figure sounds quite generous, but if you voted Conservative, you're likely already in the 'every man for himself' mentality. Which means you might have misread a vital part of that statement, 'any household'.

£23,000 sounds like a decent wage (especially if you think benefits claimants are sitting around all day doing nothing), but it's per household, and it's the maximum. So lots of people will be receiving significantly less than this, and if you're in a two-person household, it's the equivalent of earning £11,500 per year each, at the very most. Hmmm, not so generous now.

The next problem with this, is that everyone lives to their means. That's why when you get a pay rise, a few months later you can't imagine how you survived on less cash. If you suddenly started receiving £230 less each month (which is what this new benefits cap equates to for the households receiving the maximum), you might have to cut back on your morning latte. For some, it's going to mean the difference between heating and eating.

What's more, the Conservative Party wants to stop people aged between 18 and 21 from claiming housing benefit. I wonder what will happen to the young people who are suddenly evicted from their social housing, and need to find the significant deposit and first month's rent for a private let. Not to mention the rent every month after that. You might not be renting, you might not be receiving housing benefit, but how can you ignore the thousands of young people about to be made destitute?

That's not to mention the people living with drug and alcohol addiction, or obesity who will have their benefits cut if they refuse (or are not successful) in the treatment programmes they are offered.

It's been calculated by the IFS that these changes will save the Tory government around £1.5 billion per year, when they have pledged to reduce the welfare bill by £12 billion. I dread to think where the rest will come from.

How can you vote for a policy that robs people of such a significant amount of money that they have been deemed entitled to?

I don't understand how you can close your eyes and ears to these drastic cuts. Maybe it's not happening on your doorstep and maybe you're lucky enough to have never claimed benefits. And you're even luckier if none of your family or friends are currently claiming welfare. Maybe it's easier to dehumanise the people who will suffer when you don't know their names. But that doesn't stop it happening, and I hope you never lose your job, risk losing your home or have a family member fall on hard times, because it's going to be hard to watch when you voted for such severe austerity.

I think that's enough for now - points two and three to follow.

Friday 8 May 2015

I don't understand what happened in the UK today

I believed the opinion polls in the run up to this election. I truly believed we'd still be discussing our new coalition government for the next few days, or even weeks. I believed BBC News when they told me we might not know who governs our country until the beginning of June.

That's why I didn't believe the first exit polls. Watching the alternative election coverage at home, alone was surreal. I wanted someone to tell me I was interpreting the numbers wrong, but I wasn't. I took a picture of the screen and sent it out on What'sApp: "We're leaving the country if they get a majority." Came the reply, he didn't didn't believe the numbers either.

Feeling so emotional about this election result took me by surprise. I had to choose between my head and my heart in the polling booth and I didn't think I cared as much about the outcome as I did. And that's part of what I don't understand. The other part is - I don't understand why you voted Tory.

I wanted to vote Green, but I don't wholeheartedly believe in some of their policies. But I also really, really didn't want another Conservative government. I did lots of research, and lots of those quizzes (which told me I support Conservative, Liberal Democrat, Labour and Green - so a massive help, obviously). The most striking thing I found was that the policies I like most about Green, are actually fundamental to Labour too - although there are still LOTS of Labour policies I don't believe in either. I can see why people are confused.

The constituency I live in was predicted to swing from Liberal Democrat to a Labour majority. By voting Green in my area, I could have inadvertently kept the Liberal Democrats in power here.

Labour won in my constituency. By a landslide actually. But it wasn't even nearly enough.

I went to bed late last night, and every hour or so I'd wake up in the darkness and refresh the BBC election results screen on my phone to find yet another few seats had been snatched away by the Tories. By the time it was light, and close to 5am the deal was pretty much done. I was awake then, confused. Confused because the opinion polls had me convinced. Confused because almost everyone I know is a vocal Labour, Green or SNP supporter and I'm not exposed to much in the way of Tory politics among the people I spend time with.

I'm also confused, and this is the big one. I'm confused because I cannot understand how anyone can live their life in the 'every man for himself' mentality that Conservative promotes. I want to understand your position, I'd be willing to listen if I knew someone willing to talk to me about it honestly and without resorting to a shouting match and sweeping generalisations about 'benefits cheats', 'immigrants' and 'the working class'.

I don't understand how you can vote for a party committed to cutting benefits from society's most vulnerable people, including veterans, disabled people and children. I don't understand how you can vote for a party that vilifies the same vulnerable groups to cover up the real problems in our country. Immigrants and benefits cheats are categorically NOT costing the UK as much as tax evasion, corporate loopholes and bankers' bonuses. I don't understand how you can actively go and vote for a party that lets this happen. How can you close your eyes to the cuts, the austerity, the homelessness and poverty and vote for a party that's going to make those things worse?

I'm writing this to figure this out for myself. I'm going to dig deeper. And through the hot tears that I can feel behind my eyes as I read article after article that tell me how the next five years will be (I cry when I'm angry, not just when I'm upset, it's pretty annoying) I'll dig to find the truth, to really understand the policies that are important to me. And hopefully figure out what's prompted such a strong reaction against this government in my opinion. After all, I'm not in the majority and 11,334,920 people obviously saw something to vote for, even if I don't get it.

I don't expect discover much that I like about the Conservative Party and its policies, but at least I'll have the ammunition to stand up for myself and what I believe in when I'm in the next challenging conversation.

Here are some things I intend to do, and you could to, no matter what you believe:
Join a party I truly believe in (if I can find one)
Communicate with my local MP
Volunteer
Support relevant activism, petitions and protests
Stay informed - we all did a lot of research this time round, and I'm not going to stop learning